[Article] On the Contraposition of Cultural Marxism and Christianity

On the Contraposition of Cultural Marxism and Christianity

Paper presented as a lecturer assistant at Theological Philosophy Seminary in Eastern Indonesia (2019) with minor adjustments. Lecturer: Rev. Dr. Abialtar Papalan, M.Th.

Introduction

The concepts of Cultural Marxism and Christianity represent two significant frameworks that have profoundly shaped societal values, ethical systems, and cultural discussions throughout history. Christianity, a global religion with billions of adherents, provides a comprehensive worldview encompassing beliefs about God, humanity, salvation, and morality.1 Cultural Marxism, a term with a more complex and contested history, is understood within academic circles as a development of Marxist thought that analyzes culture and society through the lens of power, ideology, and social structures, particularly drawing from the intellectual traditions of the Frankfurt School and the theories of Antonio Gramsci.3 In contemporary discourse, the relationship between these two frameworks has become increasingly relevant, often marked by polarized discussions and debates, particularly surrounding the term "Cultural Marxism" and its implications for Christian faith and practice.

This paper aims to analyze the intricate relationship between Cultural Marxism and Christianity, exploring the fundamental points of conflict that arise from their differing worldviews and identifying potential areas for reconciliation and constructive engagement. By relying on scholarly research published in academic journals, this analysis will delve into the definition and historical development of "Cultural Marxism," examine the core tenets of Christian theology, highlight the key areas of divergence between these two systems of thought, explore possibilities for common ground, investigate the role of liberation theology as a point of intersection, and analyze social movements through both Marxist and Christian perspectives. The goal is to provide a rigorous and nuanced understanding of this complex interplay, contributing to a more informed and thoughtful dialogue on the relationship between these influential forces in contemporary society.

Defining the Discourse: Conceptualizing Cultural Marxism

The term "Cultural Marxism" holds a dual significance, functioning both as a theoretical framework within academic discourse and as a central element in a prominent conspiracy theory, particularly within certain segments of political commentary.3 Understanding this distinction is crucial for a nuanced analysis of its relationship with Christianity.

Academic Interpretations of "Cultural Marxism"

Within academic disciplines such as cultural studies, sociology, and political theory, "Cultural Marxism" is generally understood as a lineage of thought that extends traditional Marxist analysis beyond the economic sphere to encompass the realm of culture.4 This theoretical development gained significant momentum in the 20th century, particularly with the emergence of the Frankfurt School of Critical Theory. This group of interdisciplinary thinkers, including figures like Theodor Adorno, Max Horkheimer, and Herbert Marcuse, sought to understand why the proletarian revolution predicted by classical Marxism had not materialized in Western Europe and why, instead, phenomena like fascism had taken root. Their work involved a critical examination of culture, mass media, and ideology as powerful forces that shape consciousness and maintain social control in capitalist societies. The Frankfurt School's approach was rooted in a synthesis of Marxist and Hegelian philosophy, incorporating insights from psychoanalysis, sociology, and other disciplines to critique the industrialization of culture and its impact on individual autonomy.6 They argued that culture was no longer an autonomous realm but had become thoroughly commodified, serving to pacify and integrate individuals into the existing capitalist system.

Another key figure in the development of Cultural Marxism as an academic concept is Antonio Gramsci, an Italian Marxist theorist. Gramsci's concept of cultural hegemony provides a crucial framework for understanding how dominant ideologies are maintained not just through force but also through the consent of the governed.7 He argued that the ruling capitalist class, or bourgeoisie, establishes and maintains its control by propagating its own values, norms, and beliefs through various social institutions such as schools, churches, media, and popular culture.7 These bourgeois values become accepted as "common sense," shaping the worldview of the working class and other classes, leading them to identify their own good with the good of the bourgeoisie and thus contributing to the maintenance of the status quo.7 Gramsci emphasized that for a socialist revolution to succeed in the West, it was necessary to first achieve cultural hegemony by developing a counter-hegemonic culture that could challenge and replace the dominant bourgeois ideology. This "war of position" involved a long-term struggle over ideas and beliefs within civil society.

"Cultural Marxism" as a Conspiracy Theory

In contrast to its academic usage, "Cultural Marxism" has also emerged as a prominent conspiracy theory, particularly gaining traction in the United States starting in the 1990s and becoming increasingly prevalent in far-right political discourse.3 This conspiratorial interpretation posits that a small group of Marxist critical theorists, often associated with the Frankfurt School, have intentionally infiltrated universities, media, and other cultural institutions to undermine Western civilization and its traditional values, including Christianity.3 According to this theory, these "Cultural Marxists" promote ideologies such as multiculturalism, political correctness, feminism, LGBTQ+ rights, and environmentalism as part of a deliberate plot to weaken Western societies from within, leading to moral and aesthetic decline.3

This conspiracy theory often carries antisemitic undertones, frequently blaming Jewish intellectuals of the Frankfurt School for orchestrating this cultural subversion.9 The narrative often exaggerates the influence and power of the Frankfurt School, falsely claiming that they control all areas of public life, including media, schools, entertainment, and government.10 The term "Cultural Marxism" in this context has become a pejorative label used by some conservative and far-right groups to dismiss any views or movements they disagree with, particularly those perceived as socially progressive or challenging traditional norms.14 Scholars have noted the problematic nature of this term due to its frequent use in irrational conspiracy theories and its association with hate speech and extremist ideologies.3 It is crucial to distinguish this conspiratorial usage from the academic study of culture and power influenced by Marxist thought.

Foundational Principles: Core Tenets of Christian Theology

To analyze the relationship between Cultural Marxism and Christianity, it is essential to outline the core tenets of Christian theology, providing a basis for identifying both potential areas of conflict and possibilities for constructive engagement.

The Nature of God

Christian theology centers on the belief in one God who exists eternally in three co-equal persons: the Father, the Son (Jesus Christ), and the Holy Spirit—a doctrine known as the Trinity.1 This God is understood to be omnipotent (all-powerful), omniscient (all-knowing), omnipresent (present everywhere), and absolutely sovereign over all creation.2 God is the ultimate Creator and sustainer of the universe, bringing everything into existence and upholding it by His power.1 Furthermore, Christian theology ascribes numerous attributes to God, including perfect love, infinite justice, absolute holiness, boundless grace, and unwavering faithfulness.1 These attributes define God's character and inform the Christian understanding of ethics, morality, and the nature of reality.

Human Nature and the Fall

Christian theology teaches that humanity was created by God in His own image (Imago Dei), bestowing upon human beings inherent dignity, worth, and a unique capacity for relationship with God.1 This image includes attributes such as reason, creativity, and a moral conscience. However, the foundational narrative of the Fall describes humanity's rebellion against God through the sin of Adam and Eve, which introduced sin, death, and alienation into the world.1 This original sin resulted in a state of human depravity, meaning that every aspect of human nature has been affected by sin, rendering humanity incapable of perfectly fulfilling God's righteous standards and in need of divine redemption.2

Salvation and Redemption

The central message of Christian theology is the offer of salvation and redemption from sin and its consequences through faith in Jesus Christ.1 Christians believe that Jesus Christ, the Son of God, became fully human, lived a sinless life, died on the cross as an atoning sacrifice for the sins of humanity, and rose again from the dead, conquering sin and death.2 Salvation is understood as a gift of God's grace, freely offered to all who place their trust and faith in Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, leading to forgiveness of sins, reconciliation with God, and the promise of eternal life.1 This redemption is not earned through human effort but is received by grace through faith.

Justice and Ethics

The Christian understanding of justice is rooted in the character of God, who is perfectly just and righteous.18 God's commandments, as revealed in the Bible, provide the foundation for Christian ethics, calling believers to love God and their neighbor as themselves.18 This includes a mandate to care for the poor, the oppressed, and the marginalized in society, reflecting God's own concern for the vulnerable.18 Christian ethics emphasize principles such as love, compassion, fairness, honesty, and the upholding of human dignity, all derived from the nature and will of God as revealed in Scripture.

Points of Divergence: Examining the Conflicts Between Cultural Marxism and Christianity

Despite some superficial overlaps, the fundamental worldviews of Cultural Marxism and Christianity diverge in significant ways, leading to inherent conflicts in their understanding of reality, human nature, and the solutions to societal problems.

Materialism vs. Transcendence

A primary point of divergence lies in their ontological frameworks. While Christianity posits the existence of a transcendent God who created the universe and continues to sustain it, Marxism, in its classical form and as often reflected in Critical Theory, tends towards a materialist worldview.17 This materialism often views reality as fundamentally composed of matter and energy, with little or no room for a spiritual realm or a divine being.23 Karl Marx himself was an atheist who famously described religion as "the opium of the people," suggesting it serves to pacify the oppressed rather than offering genuine hope or liberation.23 This materialist perspective contrasts sharply with the Christian belief in a God who is both transcendent (existing beyond the material world) and immanent (actively involved in it).2

Furthermore, their views on human nature also differ significantly. Christianity teaches that humans are created in God's image, possessing inherent spiritual and moral dimensions.2 While acknowledging the impact of social and economic factors, Christian anthropology emphasizes the unique value and dignity of each individual as a creation of God. In contrast, Marxist perspectives often view human nature as primarily shaped by social and economic conditions, with individuals understood largely in terms of their relationship to the means of production or their position within systems of power.26 This difference in understanding the fundamental nature of humanity has profound implications for their respective analyses of societal problems and their proposed solutions.

Sin vs. Oppression as the Primary Problem

Another key area of conflict arises in their identification of the primary problem facing humanity. Christian theology posits that sin, in its various forms of rebellion against God and violation of His moral law, is the root cause of human suffering, injustice, and alienation.17 This understanding emphasizes the fallen nature of humanity and the need for individual and collective repentance and spiritual transformation through God's grace.17 While acknowledging the reality of social injustices, Christianity ultimately points to the broken relationship between humanity and God as the fundamental issue.

In contrast, Critical Theory, and by extension, Cultural Marxism, often identifies systemic oppression as the primary problem.29 This perspective emphasizes the existence of power hierarchies and the ways in which dominant groups maintain their advantage by oppressing and marginalizing subordinate groups based on factors like race, class, gender, and sexuality.19 While acknowledging the reality of individual sin, Critical Theory tends to focus on the societal structures and systems that perpetuate inequality as the main source of human suffering and injustice.29 This difference in identifying the core problem leads to divergent approaches to achieving justice and societal transformation, with Christianity emphasizing spiritual renewal and Critical Theory focusing on dismantling oppressive systems.

Views on Key Institutions: Family, Church, State

Their differing worldviews also lead to contrasting perspectives on key societal institutions such as the family, the church, and the state. Christian theology typically upholds the traditional nuclear family as divinely ordained and foundational to a healthy society. It emphasizes specific roles and responsibilities within the family unit based on biblical teachings. In contrast, Critical Theory often critiques traditional family structures as potentially patriarchal and oppressive, advocating for more fluid and diverse understandings of family.

Regarding the church, Marxism famously viewed religion as "the opium of the people," a tool used by the ruling class to pacify the oppressed and maintain their dominance.27 This perspective stands in direct opposition to the Christian understanding of the church as the body of Christ, a community of believers called to worship God, proclaim the Gospel, and serve others.2 While some forms of liberation theology have attempted to reconcile Marxist analysis with Christian faith, significant tensions remain regarding the role and authority of the church in addressing social issues.32

Finally, their views on the state and the means of achieving social change also differ. While Christianity acknowledges the role of government in maintaining order and justice, it ultimately points to the Kingdom of God as the ultimate hope for a just and peaceful world, achieved through spiritual transformation and the return of Christ.34 Marxism, on the other hand, often advocates for revolutionary action to overthrow existing social and political orders seen as inherently oppressive, aiming to establish a classless society through the power of the state.17

Seeking Common Ground: Exploring Potential for Reconciliation and Engagement

Despite these fundamental differences, there are potential areas where Christianity and the concerns underlying Cultural Marxism might find some common ground for dialogue and even limited engagement.

Shared Concern for Social Justice and the Poor

One significant area of overlap lies in the shared concern for social justice, equality, and the well-being of the marginalized and the poor.20 Christian theology, rooted in the teachings of Jesus Christ and the Old Testament prophets, places a strong emphasis on caring for the poor, the widow, the orphan, and all those who are vulnerable and oppressed.32 Jesus' own ministry was characterized by compassion for the suffering and a commitment to justice.36 Similarly, the impetus behind much of Critical Theory and the concern for "Cultural Marxism" often stems from a desire to address social inequalities and dismantle systems that are perceived as unjust and oppressive.19 While their ultimate motivations and the frameworks they use to understand and address these issues differ, the practical aim of seeking a more just and equitable society can be a point of contact. Christians can acknowledge and affirm the desire for justice and the alleviation of suffering that motivates many proponents of critical perspectives, even if they disagree with the underlying philosophical assumptions.19

Critical Analysis of Societal Structures

Both Christianity, particularly through certain theological traditions, and Cultural Marxism, as an outgrowth of Critical Theory, offer a critical lens for examining societal structures and power dynamics.14 While their approaches differ significantly, both encourage a questioning of the status quo and a scrutiny of how power operates within society.19 Christian theology, when engaging with social issues, can involve a critical assessment of unjust systems and practices in light of biblical principles of righteousness and justice.18 The concept of "Biblical Critical Theory" itself suggests an attempt to use the Bible as a framework for critically analyzing culture and society.39 Therefore, Christians can engage with the critical insights offered by Cultural Marxism and Critical Theory regarding the existence and impact of power structures and systemic inequalities, using these insights to inform their own pursuit of biblical justice.18 This does not necessarily entail adopting the entire theoretical framework but rather discerning specific analyses that might align with or illuminate areas of injustice that Christians are also called to address.

Potential for Dialogue and Mutual Learning

Despite the fundamental differences, there is potential for dialogue and mutual learning between Christians and those who approach social issues from a Marxist or critical perspective.19 Meaningful dialogue requires both sides to listen and understand the concerns and perspectives of the other. Christians can seek to understand the lived experiences of marginalized groups, which are often highlighted within critical theory, and engage with the analyses of power dynamics and systemic inequalities that these perspectives offer.19 At the same time, Christians can offer a robust theological and ethical framework for understanding and addressing these issues, rooted in their belief in God, human nature, sin, and redemption.25 This mutual engagement, while requiring discernment and a commitment to one's own foundational beliefs, could lead to a more profound understanding of complex societal issues and potentially more effective and holistic approaches to promoting justice and human flourishing from a Christian perspective.

The Praxis of Liberation: Analyzing Liberation Theology as a Point of Intersection

Liberation theology represents a significant theological movement that emerged in the late 20th century, primarily in Latin America, as an explicit attempt to bridge Christian faith with a concern for the liberation of the poor and oppressed.32 This movement provides a crucial case study for analyzing the complex relationship between Marxist thought and Christian theology.

History and Key Themes of Liberation Theology

Liberation theology arose in response to the socio-economic injustices and political oppression prevalent in many Latin American countries.32 It emphasizes the application of religious faith to help the poor and oppressed through involvement in political and civic affairs.32 A key theme is the "preferential option for the poor," which prioritizes the needs and perspectives of the marginalized, believing that God speaks particularly through them and that the Bible can only be truly understood from their perspective.32 Liberation theologians stress the importance of understanding the "sinful" socioeconomic structures that cause social inequities and actively working to change them.32 This involves a strong emphasis on social justice, advocating for active engagement in political and civic affairs as a means to aid the poor and oppressed.32

Liberation Theology's Engagement with Marxist Thought

A distinctive feature of liberation theology is its engagement with Marxist social analysis, particularly its critique of structural inequality and class oppression.32 Liberation theologians utilized Marxist tools to analyze the root causes of poverty and injustice in their societies, identifying systemic issues within capitalist economic and political structures.33 While liberation theology did not adopt Marxism wholesale, its use of concepts like class struggle and the critique of global capitalism led to significant controversy within the Catholic Church and among other Christian denominations.32 The movement sought to reconcile Marxist insights regarding social analysis with Christian faith, often interpreting the teachings of Jesus and the concept of the Kingdom of God in light of the struggles of the poor and oppressed.33 Some proponents argued that Marxist analysis could help Christians understand the material conditions of injustice and develop more effective strategies for liberation, viewing the Kingdom of God not merely as a future reality but as something to be actively worked for in the present through the transformation of unjust social structures.42

Critiques of Liberation Theology from Christian Perspectives

Liberation theology has faced considerable criticism from various Christian perspectives. One major concern revolves around the potential for it to prioritize political and economic liberation over the spiritual redemption of individuals, thus potentially reducing the Gospel to a purely earthly message.28 Critics have also raised concerns about the uncritical adoption of Marxist ideologies, particularly its atheistic and materialistic foundations, arguing that these are fundamentally incompatible with Christian beliefs.28 The debate often centers on whether Marxist social analysis can be separated from its broader philosophical and ideological framework, with some arguing that accepting Marxist analysis inevitably leads to accepting its underlying worldview, which contradicts core tenets of Christian faith.28 Furthermore, some critics argue that liberation theology's emphasis on class struggle and revolutionary action is inconsistent with the Christian call to love one's enemies and pursue peace.33 Despite these critiques, liberation theology remains a significant movement that highlights the ongoing tension and dialogue between Christian faith and social justice concerns, particularly in relation to Marxist-inspired analyses of power and oppression.

Social Movements Through Marxist and Christian Lenses

Examining specific social movements through the lenses of both Cultural Marxism/Critical Theory and Christian theology can further illuminate the areas of conflict and potential reconciliation between these two frameworks.

Feminist Movements

Feminist movements, broadly defined as efforts to achieve equality and liberation for women, have often drawn upon critical theory for their analysis of patriarchy and systemic inequalities. From a critical theory perspective, feminist movements aim to challenge and dismantle the power structures that disadvantage women in patriarchal societies, critiquing misogyny, sexism, and the social construction of gender roles. Methods employed often include political activism, social protest, consciousness-raising, and the development of feminist theory to understand and challenge patriarchal norms.

Christian theological perspectives on feminist movements are diverse. There is often agreement on the fundamental principle of equality between men and women, rooted in the Christian belief that both are created in God's image and are equal heirs of God's grace. Many Christian feminists advocate for equal rights, opportunities, and treatment for women in all spheres of life. However, disagreements often arise regarding the interpretation of scripture concerning gender roles, authority within the family and church, and issues related to sexuality and reproductive rights. Some Christian perspectives emphasize complementarity rather than strict egalitarianism in certain roles, while others find aspects of radical feminism to be incompatible with biblical teachings. Nevertheless, the shared concern for justice and the recognition of women's inherent dignity provide potential areas for dialogue and engagement between feminist movements and Christian communities.

Anti-Racism Movements (e.g., Black Lives Matter)

Anti-racism movements, such as Black Lives Matter, which emerged in response to racial injustice and systemic violence against Black people, often utilize critical race theory, a branch of critical theory, to analyze the pervasive nature of racism and advocate for racial justice. From this perspective, racism is understood not merely as individual prejudice but as deeply embedded within institutions, laws, and policies, perpetuating racial inequality. The goals of these movements include combating police brutality, addressing systemic racism in various sectors of society, and affirming the value and dignity of Black lives. Methods employed range from online activism and social media campaigns to protests, demonstrations, and political advocacy.

Christian theological analyses of anti-racism movements reveal both alignment and conflict. The Christian commitment to justice, love for neighbor, and the inherent value of every human life created in God's image often leads to strong support for the goals of racial equality and the dismantling of racial injustice. Many Christians actively participate in anti-racism efforts, recognizing the moral imperative to address racial disparities and advocate for the marginalized. However, potential conflicts can arise regarding certain aspects of these movements' ideologies or methods, particularly concerning views on family structure, sexuality, and authority, as well as critiques of capitalism and other societal norms. Some Christian perspectives also emphasize the importance of addressing individual sin and the need for reconciliation through Christ as foundational to achieving lasting racial harmony. Despite these potential tensions, the fundamental Christian call to justice and the inherent dignity of all people provide significant common ground for engagement with anti-racism movements.

Conclusion: Towards a More Profound Understanding of a Complex Interplay

The relationship between Cultural Marxism and Christianity is multifaceted and complex, characterized by fundamental conflicts in their worldviews yet also marked by potential areas for dialogue and engagement. Their differing ontological commitments—materialism versus theism—lead to divergent understandings of human nature, the primary problems facing humanity, and the ultimate solutions. While Christianity identifies sin as the root issue requiring spiritual redemption, Cultural Marxism often emphasizes systemic oppression necessitating societal transformation. These differing diagnoses result in contrasting perspectives on key institutions like family, church, and state, as well as on the means of achieving social change.

However, despite these significant divergences, a crucial point of potential convergence lies in their shared concern for social justice, equality, and the well-being of the marginalized. This common ground offers an opportunity for Christians to engage with specific critiques of societal structures and power dynamics offered by Cultural Marxism and Critical Theory, even while maintaining a distinctively Christian worldview rooted in biblical principles. Meaningful dialogue and mutual learning can occur when Christians approach these perspectives with discernment, acknowledging areas of shared concern while also offering theological and ethical critiques of underlying assumptions.

Liberation theology serves as a compelling example of an attempt to bridge Marxist social analysis with Christian faith, highlighting both the potential for addressing social injustices and the inherent theological challenges of such a synthesis. The analysis of social movements like feminism and Black Lives Matter through both critical theory and Christian theological lenses reveals a complex interplay of shared values in seeking justice and equality, alongside potential conflicts regarding differing ideologies and specific goals.

Navigating the contemporary cultural and theological landscape requires a nuanced understanding of these complex dynamics. The term "Cultural Marxism" itself is highly contested, often employed within conspiratorial narratives that misrepresent academic concepts and carry harmful antisemitic undertones. Therefore, it is essential to approach this topic with intellectual honesty, theological integrity, and a commitment to both biblical truth and genuine social concern. Continued scholarly engagement and dialogue between these influential frameworks, marked by careful listening and respectful critique, can foster greater understanding and contribute to more effective and holistic approaches to addressing the multifaceted challenges facing society today.

Bibliography

1. The Seven Core Tenets of the Christian Faith | Mission Save Montana, https://www.missionsavemontana.com/the-seven-core-tenets-of-the-christian-faith/
2. Cultural Marxism: A survey - ResearchGate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/322979466_Cultural_Marxism_A_survey
3. Cultural Marxism, British cultural studies, and the reconstruction of education, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00131857.2021.1926982
4. Cultural Marxism: Imaginary Conspiracy or Revolutionary Reality? - The Gospel Coalition, https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/themelios/article/cultural-marxism-imaginary-conspiracy-or-revolutionary-reality/
5. Frankfurt School | History, Features, & Facts | Britannica, https://www.britannica.com/topic/Frankfurt-School
6. Antonio Gramsci - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonio_Gramsci
7. What Is Cultural Hegemony? - ThoughtCo, https://www.thoughtco.com/cultural-hegemony-3026121
8. Special Briefing: Cultural Marxism: An Antisemitic Conspiracy Theory?, https://antisemitism.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Cultural-Marxism-October-2020.pdf
9. Who's Afraid of the Frankfurt School? “Cultural Marxism” as an Antisemitic Conspiracy Theory Joan Braune1 - Transformative Studies Institute, https://transformativestudies.org/wp-content/uploads/Joan-Braune.pdf
10. 'Cultural Marxism' Catching On - Southern Poverty Law Center, https://www.splcenter.org/resources/reports/cultural-marxism-catching/
11. Cultural Marxism: Far Right Antisemitic Conspiracy Theory? - Psychology Today, https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/rabble-rouser/202103/cultural-marxism-far-right-anti-semitic-conspiracy-theory
12. Cultural Marxism & Christianity | the Way?, https://the-way.info/culture/cultural-marxism/
13. Our Doctrinal Core | National Association of Evangelicals, https://www.nae.org/our-doctrinal-core/
14. Is Cultural Marxism Compatible with Christianity? | Christians ..., https://christiansengaged.org/blog/cultural-marxism-vs-biblical-worldview
15. A Biblical Critique of Secular Justice and Critical Theory - Gospel in Life, https://gospelinlife.com/article/a-biblical-critique-of-secular-justice-and-critical-theory/
16. Critical Theory vs. Christianity - STR.org, https://www.str.org/w/critical-theory-vs-christianity
17. The Recurring Christian Debate about Social Justice:, https://sociologyandchristianity.org/index.php/jsc/article/download/229/211/423
18. Cultural Marxism - Founders Ministries, https://founders.org/sermons/cultural-marxism/
19. Priority Reading for 2022: Jon Harris's Christianity and Social Justice: Religions in Conflict, https://wordfoundations.com/2021/12/30/25371/
20. Karl Marx's Struggle with God: the Destruction of Christianity - ARC Journals, https://www.arcjournals.org/pdfs/ijps/v9-i1/3.pdf
21. marx's new religion . . . robert f. schwarzwalder jr. - Evangelical Theological Society, https://etsjets.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/files_JETS-PDFs_62_62-4_JETS_62.4_775-788_SchwarzwalderJr.pdf
22. Can I be a Christian and a Marxist? Q&A - The Gospel Coalition ...,  https://au.thegospelcoalition.org/article/can-christian-marxist-qa/
23. A Theological Appraisal of Marxism | Via Emmaus, https://davidschrock.com/2022/07/20/a-theological-appraisal-of-marxism/
24. interrogating karl marx's critique of religion from the lens of the prosperity gospel message in - ACJOL.Org, https://acjol.org/index.php/crowther/article/download/6419/6213
25. Why Marxism is an Acid Bath that Corrodes the Christian View of Justice & Liberation, https://bruceashford.net/2019/why-marxism-is-an-acid-bath-that-corrodes-the-christian-view-of-justice-liberation/
26. The Incompatibility of Critical Theory and Christianity - The Gospel Coalition, https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/incompatibility-critical-theory-christianity/
27. Neil Shenvi: Are Social Justice, Critical Theory, and Christianity Compatible?,  https://cfc.sebts.edu/faith-and-culture/neil-shenvi-are-social-justice-critical-theory-and-christianity-compatible/
28. White Privilege & Cultural Marxism - Four12 Global, https://four12global.com/articles/white-privilege-cultural-marxism/
29. Liberation theology | Definition, Meaning, History, & Beliefs | Britannica, https://www.britannica.com/topic/liberation-theology
30. Liberation Theology: A Marxist Christianity? How Latin American priests utilised Marxism to fight against dictators, by Jack Collicutt - Manchester Historian,  https://manchesterhistorian.com/2020/liberation-theology-a-marxist-christianity-how-latin-american-priests-utilised-marxism-to-fight-against-dictators-by-jack-collicutt/
31. Christianity and Communism - New Evangelizers, https://newevangelizers.com/blog/2019/05/13/christianity-and-communism/
32. Utopia vs. The Kingdom of God (6/17) | Fairfield Christian Church, https://www.fairfieldchristian.org/2021/06/utopia-vs-the-kingdom-of-god-6-17/
33. Christians and cultural Marxism | the Way?, https://the-way.info/2021/03/07/christians-and-cultural-marxism/
34. The Synthetic Gospel of Liberation Theology - Kuyperian Commentary -,  https://kuyperian.com/the-synthetic-gospel-of-liberation-theology/
35. Christianity and Critical Theory – Part 1 - Neil Shenvi - Apologetics, https://shenviapologetics.com/critical-theory-and-christianity-part-1/
36. Critical Theory and the Bible: Unpacking Modern Life with Dr. Christopher Watkin | POD 037, https://cckc.church/podcast/critical-theory-and-the-bible-christopher-watkin/
37. Robert Smith: Cultural Marxism: Imaginary Conspiracy or Revolutionary Reality?, http://pneumareview.com/robert-smith-cultural-marxism-imaginary-conspiracy-or-revolutionary-reality/
38. liberation theology and marx - lauren's A level religious studies revision - WordPress.com, https://laurenrevisesphilosophy.wordpress.com/2019/06/14/liberation-theology-and-marx/
39. Liberation (Liberal) Theology Open To Marxist Seduction - Christendom Media, https://media.christendom.edu/1985/07/liberation-liberal-theology-open-to-marxist-seduction/

Author:

Edward Daniel Simamora

Researcher, Center for Religious and Philosophy Studies
Theological Philosophy Seminary of Eastern Indonesia

Makassar, Indonesia
simamora_edward@yahoo.co.id